Best HR and Payroll Software for Healthcare Organizations

This guide is built for healthcare payroll and HR leaders managing clinical workforces.

• HR and People Ops leaders in hospitals, skilled nursing, and long-term care facilities.
• Payroll and Finance directors managing complex shift differentials and multi-state tax compliance.
• Operations leaders responsible for CMS compliance, including PBJ reporting.
• Practice managers at independent clinics and dental offices looking to streamline staff and contractor payments.

Strong vendor fit in this category requires moving beyond basic payroll processing.

• Native PBJ reporting — The system automatically tracks direct care and contractor hours to generate submission-ready XML files for CMS.
• Advanced shift differentials — The rules engine automates evening, weekend, holiday, hazard, and call-back pay without manual calculation.
• Credential-based scheduling — The platform maps nursing licenses to the schedule, actively preventing lapsed or uncertified staff from working.
• Multi-state tax compliance — The system seamlessly handles taxation for travel nurses and staff working across different state lines.
• EHR and GL integration — Payroll data flows smoothly into Electronic Health Records and accounting software to correlate labor costs with patient outcomes.

Choose UKG if…

• You operate a 24/7 hospital or skilled nursing facility.
• You need native, automated PBJ reporting for CMS compliance.
• You require complex shift differentials and credential-based scheduling.

Choose ADP Workforce Now if…

• You manage a multi-location clinic network across several states.
• You employ travel nurses and need bulletproof multi-state tax compliance.
• You want a highly reliable, scalable payroll engine with a massive integration marketplace.

Choose Paycor if…

• You are a mid-sized long-term care group or regional clinic (50–1,000 employees).
• You need actionable dashboards to monitor overtime and control labor costs.
• You want a user-friendly interface with strong general ledger integration.

Choose Workday HCM if…

• You are a large enterprise health system or academic medical center.
• You need a unified platform for HR, finance, and complex physician compensation.
• You have the budget and IT resources for a major enterprise deployment.

Choose Gusto if…

• You run a small private practice, dental office, or independent clinic.
• You need an easy, transparently priced system for a mix of W-2 staff and 1099 contractors.
• You do not require PBJ reporting or complex 24/7 scheduling rules.

Healthcare payroll in the US is heavily dictated by state-specific labor laws and federal mandates. Under ACA Section 6106, long-term care facilities are mandated to electronically submit direct care staffing information quarterly. Reports must be submitted via XML or manual entry within 45 days of the end of each fiscal quarter. Note that as of 2018, CMS derives census data from MDS resident assessments, eliminating the need for PBJ census submission. Organizations employing travel nurses or operating telehealth services across state lines face complex multi-state taxation. Compliance with the FLSA '8 and 80' rule requires prior employee agreement and a payroll system capable of automatically calculating overtime for hours worked over 8 in a day or 80 in a 14-day period [04]. Under Section 7(j), hospitals and residential care establishments may use this 14-day work period instead of a 7-day week.

Pricing in the healthcare payroll market is heavily segmented by organization size and the complexity of workforce management modules required. Rule of thumb: Small practices: Transparent base fees (e.g., $49 or $80) plus per-employee fees. Mid-market to Enterprise: Quote-based pricing for software tiers. Costs scale based on employee headcount and the addition of specialized modules like advanced Time & Attendance or PBJ reporting. Large Health Systems: Enterprise quote-based models with variable implementation fees, reflecting the complexity of unifying finance, HR, and clinical payroll data.

This page is a scenario-specific ranking based on the shared research and the criteria most relevant to this buying situation. We weighted ability to handle complex healthcare scheduling and shift differentials, support for industry-specific compliance (particularly PBJ reporting), multi-state tax capabilities for distributed or travel staff, integration depth with credential tracking and general ledger systems, and platform scalability and ease of use for the target facility size. Vendor capabilities can change based on the specific modules purchased. Implementation success heavily depends on your internal data readiness and IT resources. This is not legal advice.

See the full methodology →