Gusto Review

Our take

Summary

Get Gusto

Gusto is a comprehensive HR and payroll SaaS solution designed for small to medium-sized U.S. businesses. It unifies core HRIS, payroll, benefits administration, hiring & onboarding, time tracking, compliance, and integrations in one platform. Gusto’s strength is in its integrated approach: employee data, payroll, time-off and benefits all sync together. Starting with a base subscription plus per-employee pricing, it allows businesses to scale from simple payroll usage to full HR management. While Gusto is U.S.-centric (states, tax forms, compliance), it provides broad support, including multi-state payroll, contractor payments, and an optional Employer-of-Record (EOR) international solution.

In the marketplace, Gusto is recognized for strong usability, comprehensive HR features for the U.S., and a reputation for reliability. However, customers sometimes flag support responsiveness and pricing as pain points.

Strengths

Integrated HR + Payroll Suite: Gusto combines payroll, benefits, HRIS, onboarding, time tracking, and compliance in one cohesive platform so that data flows seamlessly between modules.
Payroll & Tax Automation: Unlimited payroll runs, automatic tax filing, W-2/1099 generation, multi-state registration—all handled behind the scenes, reducing manual effort.
Benefits Administration: Gusto supports health insurance, 401(k), HSA, commuter benefits, and workers’ compensation inside the platform, often without extra admin fees.
Hiring & Onboarding: Offers digital offer letters, self-onboarding for new employees (tax forms, direct deposit, document collection).
Time & Attendance Tools: Integrated time tracking, PTO policies, and scheduling (in higher plans) reduce manual coordination.
U.S. Compliance Coverage: Strong coverage of U.S. regulatory and tax obligations across states, with automated updates for legislation changes.
Transparent, Tiered Pricing: Clear pricing tiers with base + per-employee cost, and optional add-ons (HR resources, support) make it easier to forecast costs.
Scalable for Growth: From small businesses to those with employees in multiple states, Gusto supports growth phases with more advanced capabilities.
Good Integration Ecosystem: Connects with accounting tools (QuickBooks, Xero), expense systems, project management apps, and more.
Strong User Experience: Users often praise Gusto’s intuitive, clean interface and smooth onboarding.

Limitations

U.S.-Only Focus: Gusto is largely built for the U.S. market; international payroll and compliance have limited support (though Gusto Global EOR is emerging).
Support Constraints at Lower Tiers: Lower-tier plans may receive slower support and fewer HR advisory services; premium support often requires upgrading or add-ons.
Add-on Costs: Many advanced features (time tracking, performance tools, priority support) come as add-ons or require higher-tier subscription, increasing total cost.
Limited Customization of Reports: Some users feel the built-in reporting and analytics have constraints when needing deeply custom or industry-specific metrics.
Scaling Cost per Employee: As team size increases, per-employee fees can add up—and for many features, you may need to move to higher tiers.
EOR Pricing Steep for Global: The Employer-of-Record service (Global) is expensive per employee in many countries relative to domestic plans.
Occasional Payroll Glitches: Some customers report infrequent errors in payroll or tax filings, which need manual correction and can erode trust.
Lack of Robust Workflow Engines: Though it automates many HR tasks, it is not designed to be a full workflow/approval engine for all business processes beyond HR.

Gusto Platform

Features Showdown Summary

Feature Category

BambooHR Features

Core HR

Employee database, documents, employee profiles, I-9, W-4 handling, workforce directories.

Payroll

Full-service payroll with unlimited runs, tax filing, garnishments, multi-state, contractor support.

Benefits Administration

Health, 401(k), insurance, deductions—all administered within Gusto; integrates with payroll.

Recruiting & Onboarding

Basic applicant tracking, offer letter generation, onboarding workflows; not a full recruiting suite.

Time & Attendance

Time tracking, PTO, scheduling (in higher plans) with hours syncing to payroll.

Global Hiring (EOR)

Gusto Global EOR exists, but is expensive and less mature than domestic features.

IT Management

No IT asset management or device provisioning modules.

Finance Management

Payroll analytics, cost-of-labor metrics; relies on integrations for broader finance functions.

Workflow Automation

Some HR automation and alerts exist, but no fully flexible workflow engine for non-HR tasks.

Integrations

Good integration with accounting, expense, project, and HR tools.

Pricing Transparency

Published pricing tiers and add-on fees; upgrade/downgrade flexibility.By quote only

Target Market Focus

Tailored to U.S. small and medium-sized organizations needing full HR + payroll.

HR Core & Employee Database

Gusto stores employee master records, demographic data, employee classification (W-2, 1099), and document storage (I-9, W-4, etc.). It lets HR manage promotions, terminations, status changes, and internal notes. Because these records feed into payroll, benefits, and reports, data consistency is maintained across modules.

Gusto stays current with U.S. labor laws, updating automatically and alerting users to compliance changes. The system maintains audit trails, stores legal documents, and helps with required reporting. In higher tiers (or with HR add-ons), users gain access to HR advisors, compliance alerts, and resource libraries.

Payroll & Compliance

Gusto’s Payroll is fully managed: users can run payroll unlimited times per month, and Gusto automatically calculates wages, deductions, employer taxes, garnishments, and files federal and state forms. It handles multi-state payroll and contractor payments. With direct deposit, off-cycle tweaks, and adjustments, it offers strong flexibility for payroll teams.

Gusto’s Payroll Feature

Benefits Administration

Gusto acts as a broker and administration hub for health insurance, 401(k), HSA, commuter benefits, and more. Employees can enroll online, and deductions sync with payroll automatically. Gusto also supports broker integrations and lets you preserve existing benefit plans.

Gusto’s Benefits Administration Feature

Time & Attendance Management

Gusto includes built-in time tracking and paid time-off (PTO) tools. Work hours input syncs into payroll. In higher-tier plans, scheduling features help managers build shifts, approve hours, and enforce break rules. PTO accrual, carry-over, and approval workflows are configurable.

Recruitment & Workflows

Through Gusto, businesses can post jobs, collect candidate applications, generate offer letters, and send electronic onboarding packets. New hires complete tax forms, set up payments, and acknowledge policies digitally. Gusto’s onboarding ensures compliance from the first day.

Reporting & Analytics

Gusto Reporting module helps businesses to achieve greater business clarity and accelerate growth with comprehensive features, including customizable reports, confidential team feedback analytics, automated compliance alerts, and additional capabilities.

Performance Management

Gusto's performance review system streamlines employee evaluations through an automated workflow that saves managers time while increasing engagement. The platform includes comprehensive performance management tools such as employee self-assessments, manager evaluation forms, and integrated career development resources. This feature provides actionable insights into team performance strengths and identifies areas requiring additional training or support, making it easier to develop talent and improve employee retention.

Cezanne’s Mission and Market Position

User Satisfaction Ratings Summary

As of October 2025, BambooHR generally received high marks for its respective strengths, below are the areas with user feedback and experiences.

Product Capability Score Summary

Integrations & Add-On Modules

Gusto integrates with major accounting platforms (QuickBooks, Xero), expense tools, time apps, project management systems, and other HR tools. These integrations ensure data flows without manual reentry. Gusto also offers APIs and partner embedding options in some plans.

Employees access a digital portal where they see pay stubs, tax forms, PTO balances, benefits, and can update info (banking, address, contacts). Gusto enables communication via in-app notifications around approvals, documents, deadlines, or policy updates. Self-service reduces HR admin load.

Areas for Consideration

Data Migration & Setup: Importing employee data, previous payroll history, benefits info, and tax registrations may require careful planning. Auditing old data for accuracy is critical.
Tax Registrations for Multi-State: If paying employees in multiple states, Gusto will assist with state registrations, but organizations should account for time delays in registrations and compliance setup.
Configuring Policies: Before going live, you must configure PTO policies, overtime rules, benefits settings, pay schedules, deduction rules, and employee permissions. Misconfiguration can lead to payroll errors.
Integration Testing: After connecting to accounting, expense, or time systems, test syncing and reconciliation workflows so discrepancies do not cascade into payroll.
Support & Add-on Strategy: Decide early whether your plan will require HR advisory, enhanced support, or advanced features, so you don’t get caught with feature gaps after launch.
Employee Communication & Training: Staff need orientation to using the self-service portal for pay stubs, tax forms, benefits enrollment, etc. A short internal launch helps reduce support load.
Compliance Watch & Updates: Although Gusto updates for laws automatically, companies should periodically review compliance alerts and make adjustments as wages, thresholds, or rules change.

Strategic Recommendations: Based on the Business Needs

Who Is BambooHR Best For: Key Considerations for Decision-Makers Ideal Customer Profile:

Businesses needing seamless payroll + HR integration with minimal administrative overhead.
Companies with cross-state or contractor workforces needing multi-state payroll and compliance coverage.
Organizations looking to move off spreadsheets, manual processes, or multiple disconnected tools.
Firms wanting advisory support, access to HR experts, and legal compliance assistance.

Not Ideal For:

Non-U.S. companies or those with global HR needs beyond the U.S. (unless adopting Gusto’s EOR product at extra cost).
Enterprises with highly customized HR workflows, global benefit complexity, or advanced workforce management beyond the scope of Gusto’s modules.
Startups or organizations that want free-tier or no-cost solutions (Gusto has no fully free version; cost builds with usage).
Companies needing sophisticated performance management, succession planning, or deep organizational modeling beyond basic hiring/evaluations.

Conclusion & Recommendations

Gusto HR is a powerful, well-rounded HR/payroll solution for U.S. businesses. Its greatest strength lies in its integrated platform that fuses payroll, benefits, HR, time tracking, and compliance, minimizing manual handoffs and complexity. For many small to mid-sized organizations, Gusto provides a solid foundation to modernize HR operations, reduce errors, and free up administrative effort.

However, its U.S.-centric legal design means companies outside the U.S. or those requiring deep global HR will find it limited or costly. Additionally, as businesses scale and require every feature, the cumulative cost of add-ons can erode some of the value. Support quality and occasional pay/tax glitches are recurring user concerns—so buyers should test thoroughly and plan for contingency or audit reviews.

If your business fits Gusto’s sweet spot (U.S.-based, scaling across states, needing full payroll + HR capabilities), it is among the top choices. For international operations or enterprises needing extensive custom HR modules, you may consider supplementing it with other tools or exploring more global HR suites.